Latest Case Notes

The book
Journal
college of law logo

Equitable interests

  • Peters v Lithgow Forge [2011] NSWSC 1185

    10 October 2011
    A solicitor obtained judgment for legal fees against a former client. The former client moved back to the USA and the only property of value in Australia is real property in the name of his company. The solicitor lodged a caveat and seeks a court...
    View More
  • Provident Capital v Agusta [2011] NSWSC 258

    01 April 2011
    A former trustee transferred trust property, in respect of which its creditor had lodged a writ to secure a judgment debt, to a new trustee. Before the transfer took place, the writ lapsed and the new trustee became the registered proprietor of the...
    View More
  • Albarran v Joe & Joe Developments [2010] NSWSC 1385

    24 November 2010
    The caveat in this case described the nature of the interest as being: An equitable interest arising under a Deed of Company Arrangement DOCA because the provisions that establish the right of equalisation are contained in the (deed of company...
    View More
  • Sundance Land Holdings P/L v Lacemore Banner P/L [2007] NSWSC 1285

    30 October 2007
    Three parties entered into heads of agreement under which they would be tenants in common of land purchased in the name of the Plaintiff (Sundance). The registered proprietor sought the removal of the caveat on the grounds that it was going to offer...
    View More
  • Girgis v Permanent Custodians [2007] NSWSC 1025

    06 September 2007
    The registered proprietor Mr Girgis made an application to extend a caveat after Perpetual Custodians (mortgagee) sold the land by auction. Mr Girgis alleged that Perpetual Custodians had over-valued the land and that the mortgage should be set aside...
    View More
  • Cellnet Group v Grigg [2006] NSWSC 1423

    12 December 2006
    The case concerned an application under section 74 O of the Real Property Act 1900 to allow a second caveat to be filed. The Court indicated that the purpose of s74O is to make sure that vexatious caveats are not lodged and not to block proper caveats...
    View More
  • Business Acquisitions Australia v Renshall [2006] NSWSC 1238

    21 November 2006
    This case concerned caveats against dealings on land under the Torrens title system. Two of the caveats claimed interests in land which lacked a solid foundation. A third caveat claimed an estate or interest described as a “charge and entitlement to...
    View More
  • McGrath v McGrath [2006] NSWSC 736

    20 July 2006
    The First Defendant lodged a caveat, the Plaintiff was the registered proprietor. The lodgement of that caveat was notified to the Defendants on 4 August 2005. On 5 August 2005 the Plaintiff lodged a lapsing notice. On 5 September 2005 the Plaintiff...
    View More
  • Jones v McQuilkin [2006] NSWSC 628

    16 June 2006
    The parties in this case were in a de facto relationship and decided to purchase and renovate a house as a joint venture. It was decided between the parties that the property should be acquired in the name of the Defendant. The Plaintiff was a builder...
    View More
  • Hutchison v Turnbull [2006] NSWSC 686

    07 April 2006
    The case concerned an application to extend a caveat. The Plaintiff and the Defendant were in a relationship which lasted for approximately two and a half years. The Defendant was advised that the Plaintiff intended to sell the property, and the...
    View More
  • (1) Thompson v White (2) White v Thompson [2006] NSWSC 110

    02 March 2006
    The Court had to determine two questions in this case. Firstly, whether the caveator had showed a prima facie claim to an interest in property. The Court indicated that the first Defendant was shown by the declarations to have been in a position in...
    View More
  • Wood v Crow [2005] NSWSC 983

    23 September 2005
    The central issue in this case was the statements made by the Plaintiff to the official receiver when, after the Defendant was made bankrupt, the official receiver inquired as to the sale of her home to the Defendant. The Court considered whether any...
    View More
  • Mango Media v Bassal [2004] NSWSC 1253

    15 December 2004
    The case concerned an application for an order that a caveat be extended until further order and a declaration that the Plaintiff has an equitable interest in the form of a charge over the land. The terms of the letter of offer between the parties...
    View More
  • Hill v Hill [2004] NSWSC 1205

    29 November 2004
    The registered proprietor sought an order for the removal of a caveat under s.74MA Real Property Act 1900. There was a contest between the parties whether, and to what extent, if any, the Defendant had an interest in the subject property. The Defendant...
    View More
  • AJDJ v PacificWest Developments [2002] NSWSC 203

    25 February 2002
    The Defendant filed a notice of motion seeking that seven separate caveats lodged by the Plaintiff be withdrawn. However, the notice of motion was dismissed based on the fact that the Court was not convinced that the existence of the caveats obstructed...
    View More
  • Ford v Birt [1999] NSWSC 238

    17 May 1999
    The case concerned an application for the extension of a caveat which expired on the date of the hearing. Counsel for the Defendant indicated numerous substantial difficulties in the existing caveat. For instance, the caveat failed to define the 100...
    View More
  • Hanover Investments v Registrar General [1999] NSWSC 21

    27 January 1999
    The case was concerned with the issue of whether a second caveat was in respect of the same interest as the first caveat. The Court referred to Section 74O of the Real Property Act 1900 which provides, that where a caveat lapses any further caveat by...
    View More